Quincy Smith on Autoplay

April 12th, 2007

In a two part interview (1, 2) with Quincy Smith on the developments occurring at CBS interactive, Staci Kramer says:

When I brought up autoplay as a way of piling up streams, Smith quickly replied: â€œThatâ€™s a cheap shot. We donâ€™t do it. … Half of that is the decision of the content provider. … In my opinion, to open something and have it directly stream in your face and then count as a stream is a cheap shot.â€

Thank god someone important finally said that.

Like this entry? You probably shouldn't follow me on Twitter here. I recommend the RSS feed instead.

8 Responses:

Matt Hoult says:

Amen. Finally some recognition of the obvious. Only a few thousand important people to go then!

#1 - April 12th, 2007 at 10:17 pm
Marc Rullo says:

One important thing to note here is that autoplay and autoplay with a stream counted seem to be two different things. The cheap shot being discussed is that content, onload, should not be double-counted. When a page loads with autoplay, the stream becomes part of the presentaion of the initial content which is considered a page view already. But autoplay is acceptable provided that it is done in context and without a hit count for the first item in a playlist.

#2 - April 13th, 2007 at 4:18 am
Mark says:

ESPN.com has the free-starting streams on their video (far right column of home page). It drives me effin’ insane. I see the play button, I can click it if I want to see last night’s Rutgers women’s basketball press conference.
Disclaimer: I love ESPN.

#3 - April 13th, 2007 at 9:03 am
Mike D. says:

Marc: I didn’t read it as a question of double counting. I read it as two things:

1. Incrementing your video starts when a user never even meant to start a video and likely isn’t even watching it is an underhanded way to pump up your video stats.

2. Doing the above is also an extremely discourteous user experience.

I do think it’s fair game to “double count” a video start and a page view if the player appears within a browser window because it *is* a video start and a page view (i.e. there are probably video ads and banner ads).

The reason this whole issue is important is that media properties are under tremendous pressure to show that they are quickly diversifying away from broadcast TV and onto the internet. So when a CEO of a major media company is asked at his quarterly or yearly meetings “how many videos have we streamed”, that number should be going up dramatically at every meeting. Autoplay is a cheap (and bad) way to help that happen.

#4 - April 13th, 2007 at 9:05 am
Jameson Huckaba says:

It’s most irritating when I have several tabs open, and each of those tabs contain autoplay streaming content. At that point I’m frantically clicking around to stop all the video/music so I can watch the one I intended to, in the order that I want to watch.

It seems like it would be possible to write a plug-in of some type that would look for autoplay content and disallow it to play until the user has given permission. This isn’t the ideal way to go, obviously, but it’s analogous to a pop-up blocker and would do the job.

#5 - April 13th, 2007 at 10:10 am
Rob Goodlatte says:

His thoughts on autoplay are dead on. I never really thought about it from the stats perspective—I’ve only thought about it from the annoyed user perspective.

His thoughts on embeddable clips are interesting, but I think they’re missing the point. It seems like they view embedded clips as yet another way to deliver a third-party ad. I understand his concern that advertisers’ spots may be inadvertantly placed on inappropriate sites, but I don’t think serving up ads is what embedding is all about.

I think the point of embeddable clips from the CBS Evening News or David Letterman is to advertise those shows and increase their ratings. Although I’m completely in the dark about marketing for television and I don’t fully understand the extent of what they’ll be offering, it has been my impression that others in the field allow embeds simply for ratings purposes—the Viacom/Comedy Central embeds don’t carry any ads to my knowledge.

Also, it sounds like the embeds they will offer are going to be limited to MySpace, AOL, and a few other “Distribution Portals”

#6 - April 13th, 2007 at 5:58 pm
Jacob says:

Mike

I know this is waaaaaaaay of topic, but I was curious if Newsvine has seen a steady increase in traffic since the McCain MySpace incident.

I hope to hear that not only was there a spike in traffic to Newsvine, but you guy were able to convert some of that spike in traffic to new users of Newsvine.

#7 - April 17th, 2007 at 9:02 am
Marko Dugonjic says:

Off to bookmarks entitled “how to convince clients”… thanks!

#8 - April 24th, 2007 at 6:47 am

Shared

Hundreds of headlines wash over us every day. And part of why many of us engage in this flow is because we have faith that over time, this torrent of episodic knowledge is going to cohere into something more significant: a framework for genuinely understanding an issue. And we live with it ’cause it sort of works. Eventually you hear enough buzzwords like “single-payer” and “public option” and you start to feel like you can play along.

But mounting evidence indicates that this approach to information is actually totally debilitating. Faced with a flood of headlines on an ever-increasing variety of topics, we shut off. We turn to news that doesn’t require much understanding – crime, traffic, weather – or we turn off the news altogether.

- Matt Thompson on why the way we report and consume news is precisely wrong. Matt is, of course, precisely right. If you’re at SXSW next week, I don’t know how you could justify missing this talk.

Cameron’s Colosseo letterpress poster is now available: The only question is, black or white? The black is oh so tempting!

Jon Stewart Skewers Media’s Obsession with Chat Roulette: Funniest Wii Craps reference ever, as well. It’s really interesting to me that Chat Roulette is getting this much “attention” when TinyChat has been around so much longer, essentially does the same thing and more, and is much more useful to the average person. Just goes to show how viral public sex acts can be.

"Add features and customers forever and rake in the dough.":

The 2005 email that spawned Picnik, Google’s latest buy. If you’re thinking about launching a startup, you should study this e-mail carefully. It’s a perfect example of exactly how a crazy little thought becomes a big idea, and even on its own, it’s better than most “official company business plans” people present to VCs. I gave a talk at Webstock in New Zealand a couple of weeks ago about creating a startup and I wish I had this to dissect at the time. Really good stuff.

50 Useful Coding Techniques (CSS Layouts, Visual Effects and Forms):

(via doug)

Tumblr Finally Rolls Out Comments. Sort Of. Trolls Not Welcome. :

I actually really like how clubby it is. Unfortunately it means I won’t be commenting on any Tumblrs since I don’t officially “follow” anyone besides via RSS, but that’s probably ok. Maybe the answer to the world’s wide-open commenting problem is something like this.

Episode 2 of Dan Benjamin's "The Conversation" is Live:

I was a guest on Dan Benjamin’s new weekly radio show last week, along with Merlin Mann, Christina Warren, Adam Keys, and Dave Nanian. Subjects discussed include Newsvine, keeping your own identity after becoming part of a big company, and the RADICAL concept of only publishing stuff to your readers and followers that is actually true.

LESS - Leaner CSS:

Given that pre-compiling CSS is an official “best practice” these days, why not use that compile step to extend CSS in powerful ways? LESS lets you use variables, nested rules, and other niceties at author-time to clean up your rules and keep everything tidy. I believe The Wolf made something like this a few years ago, but I haven’t heard about it since.

How 3D works, and why it's back:

Great article on the ins and outs of three dimensional imagery. Still doesn’t change my opinion that well-shot conventional cinematography is more impressive than the novelty that is Avatar.

The Importance of Removing Features:

This is one of the most useful articles I’ve read in a long time. As we work on focusing, strengthening, and simplifying Newsvine, the concepts discussed by Lukas ring true. “Saying no” has never been a strong suit of mine. It’s very helpful to remember how important of a quality it is. (via fullstopinteractive)

Newly released video of the space shuttle Challenger disaster: It was 24 years ago, I was in 5th grade, but I remember it like it was yesterday. School was stopped immediately and they wheeled out televisions in every classroom for us to watch the news footage. It’s great that this video has been released, but holy crap, how do you tuck something that away for two decades???

A nicely done british parody of 60 Minutes style video journalism. It’s easy to miss how formulaic our news is sometimes. (via B-Tizzle, originally via E-Chizzle)

Colosseo: This is why Cameron is a king and we are all just pawns in his world. I can’t wait to get my hands on this poster. I will point out, however, that the outro credits on the video need some kerning. Someone is going to lose their right hand for that.

Spezify:

New ways of searching are almost never as useful as old ways of searching. Spezify is pretty awesome though. It’s a visually interesting, never-ending, horizontally and vertically scrollable, topic explorer. I don’t think I’d use it for digging deep on anything, but to get a quick visually rich sampling of a topic, it’s quite fun (via tiff, a long time ago actually, over email).

Realism in UI Design:

Reminds me of my favorite logo design advice: “Never waste a stroke”. (via gruber)

Overshared

At the first Doughty show of the night at the Triple Door. If you're in Seattle you should come down for the 2nd at 10. Excellent!